Standards and Obligations
Make removals non-optional.
24 levers in this family
Everything before this page is an invitation. This page is where the invitations stop. Markets and subsidies reward the willing; standards and obligations conscript the rest, and at gigatonne scale the rest is most of the economy. No voluntary market has ever built an industry the size of oil and gas. Rules have.
These levers make removals non-optional.
- Performance standards write climate arithmetic into products themselves: carbon-intensity limits for materials, fuels and buildings that force every producer, not just the virtuous ones, to cut or to remove.
- Compliance mandates attach duties to actors: purchase obligations, take-back rules that make a fossil supplier responsible for its carbon the way a bottler is responsible for its bottles, and removal quotas for sectors that will still be emitting in 2050 no matter what we do.
- Targets and guidance define the destination in law: net-zero statutes, explicit removal targets, and, most underrated of all, legal definitions of “residual emissions” that decide how much of the job removal is actually allowed to do.
Obligations are the strongest lever in this book and the easiest to get wrong. Set them before supply exists and you manufacture non-compliance; set them too late and you have merely decorated the status quo. The craft is the ratchet: start at a level the market can meet, bind the escalation into law so it survives elections, and let every obligated tonne pull the supply chain up behind it. Mandates do not create industries overnight. They create certainty, and certainty creates industries.
Sub-family (Select One)
Governance Level (Select One)
PERFORMANCE STANDARDS
7 levers
Product carbon intensity standards
A legal ceiling on lifecycle carbon emissions per unit of product output.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Medium to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–4Social & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
1–3Demand Formation
2–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
Minimum carbon-storing content requirements
A legal minimum share of durably stored atmospheric carbon in covered products.
Cost
Low to Medium
Complexity
High
Timeline
Medium to Long
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
3–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
2–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
2–3Demand Formation
4–5Bankability and Cost of Capital
2–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
3–4
Low-carbon fuel standards
A tightening ceiling on the average lifecycle carbon intensity of transport fuel.
Cost
Low to Medium
Complexity
High to Very high
Timeline
Medium to Long
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
1–2Inputs & Capacity
1–3Demand Formation
2–3Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Material Authorisation and End-of-Waste Rules
Legal conditions defining when a recovered waste material becomes an authorised CDR input.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to Medium
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–2Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
2–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
2–3Demand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Green procurement criteria
Environmental requirements, including carbon removal, added to public and private purchasing decisions.
Cost
Very low to High
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Very short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Eligibility Criteria for Access to Public Land
A condition on public-land leases requiring the tenant to deliver or fund carbon removal.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Very short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–3Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Zoning and Fiscal Incentives for Stored-Carbon Construction
Planning and tax incentives rewarding developers who use carbon-storing construction materials.
Cost
Very low to High
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3COMPLIANCE MANDATES
10 levers
Carbon Take-Back Obligation
A rising duty on fossil-fuel producers and importers to permanently store a share of resulting CO₂.
Cost
Low to Medium
Complexity
High
Timeline
Medium to Long
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
2–4Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
2–4Inputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–5Bankability and Cost of Capital
2–4Policy Architecture & Coordination
3–4
Carbon Removal Compliance Options in Aviation and Maritime Fuel Mandates
Letting fuel suppliers and carriers meet part of a fuel mandate with verified carbon removals.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Medium to Very high
Timeline
Medium to Long
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Collective Fulfilment of Corporate Mitigation Obligations
Companies pool funding into an approved body that delivers removals on their collective behalf.
Cost
Medium to High
Complexity
Medium to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–2Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
1–2Demand Formation
2–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
2–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
3–4
Corporate Public-Benefit Spending Requirements for CDR
A mandated public-benefit spending duty that companies can partly meet through CDR activities.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–2Innovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
1–3Demand Formation
1–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Mandatory CDR Obligations
A legal duty on specified companies to ensure a set quantity of carbon removal by a deadline.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Medium to Very high
Timeline
Short to Long
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–5Bankability and Cost of Capital
2–4Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
CDR Requirements in Public Tenders
Public contracts that require the winning supplier to deliver verified carbon removals.
Cost
Very low to High
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
1–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
2–4Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Procurement-Linked Industrial Participation Requirements
Major procurement contracts conditioned on suppliers building domestic industrial capability.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Medium to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
N/AInnovation & Cost Reduction
1–3Social & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
2–4Demand Formation
1–3Bankability and Cost of Capital
1–3Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Restoration and Land-Use Framework Laws
A legal duty to restore degraded ecosystems to a specified condition by a set deadline.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
2–4Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
1–2Demand Formation
1–3Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
Limits on Substituting Removals for Emissions Reductions
A cap on how much carbon removal may count toward a climate target or claim.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
Organic Residue Separation and Recovery Requirements
A duty to separate organic residues so CDR processes can use cleaner recovered feedstock.
Cost
Very low to Medium
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–2Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
2–3Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
2–3Demand Formation
N/ABankability and Cost of Capital
1–2Policy Architecture & Coordination
2–3TARGETS AND GUIDANCE
7 levers
Legally Binding Net-Zero Targets
A statutory duty on government to reach net zero by a specified year.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
3–4
Statutory Carbon Budgets
Legally binding caps on cumulative emissions across successive multi-year periods.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Medium to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
3–4
Carbon Removal Targets
A specific, standalone quantity of carbon removal government commits to achieving by a set date.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
1–3Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
Net-Zero Standard Guidance
Authoritative guidance on what counts as a credible net-zero target, plan and disclosure.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to Medium
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
1–2Energy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Legal Limits on Residual Emissions
A statutory cap on the emissions allowed to remain at net zero.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Medium to High
Timeline
Short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
N/ABankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–4
Social Cost of Carbon
An official monetary value per tonne of CO₂ used across public spending and regulatory decisions.
Cost
Very low to Low
Complexity
Low to Medium
Timeline
Very short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
N/AInnovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–2Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–3
Post-Net-Zero Obligations
Continuing duties to keep emissions and removals balanced, or net-negative, after the net-zero target year.
Cost
Very low to High
Complexity
Low to High
Timeline
Very short to Medium
Integrity, Transparency & MRV
2–4Innovation & Cost Reduction
N/ASocial & Environmental Safeguards
N/AEnergy, Transport & Storage Infrastructure
N/AInputs & Capacity
N/ADemand Formation
1–3Bankability and Cost of Capital
N/APolicy Architecture & Coordination
2–4©2026 Alexander Mäkelä and Carbon Gap.
Except where otherwise indicated, this work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial–ShareAlike 4.0 International Licence.
Headline and barrier scores based on Carbon Gap analysis.